Thursday, August 9, 2012

CAFE - Chapter 7

Hello, everyone!  I excited to lead the discussion today.  I am Jana from Thinking Out Loud.  

Photobucket

I taught seventh and eighth grade social studies for four years before moving to reading for two years.  Just as I felt I was getting my feet under me, I was asked to be a literacy coach.  I have been doing that for four years and love my job.  Working with teachers is just as rewarding as working with students, and I still get work with students...best of both worlds!  As soon as I finished my Masters in Reading, I started the National Board process and achieved National Board Certification in reading two years ago.  Why am I telling you this?  Because I want you to know how much I LOVE, LOVE teaching literacy.  One of my favorite aspects is working with small groups, especially strategy groups.

Chapter 7 - STRATEGY GROUPS

We have all heard of the 'spray and pray' method (otherwise known as only teaching whole-group lessons).  We also know that it doesn't work for every student.  There is not a way to meet the needs of every student using only whole-group instruction.  However, if you combine whole-group instruction with individual conferences and strategy groups, you can meet the needs of all of your students.  The Daily 5 sets the structure of your literacy block, so you can meet with students in strategy groups while the rest of your class participates in authentic reading and writing activities.

What is a strategy group?  How is it different from guided reading?
Strategy groups are small, flexible groups that are formed based on the strategies students need instruction on and practice with instead of being in the same group because of reading level.  These groups are truly flexible.  As soon as a student has mastered the strategy, he or she is moved out of the group.  The strategy determines the frequency of which the group meets instead of meeting every day with every group.  Some groups need more practice time and less instructional time with teacher.  Some groups will need to meet with the teacher every day.

What happens during a strategy group?  
  • Students come to the group and begin reading a book from their book box aloud quietly.  As the students are reading, the teacher is listening to find out if they are using the strategy about to be introduced during that meeting.
  • The teacher verbally reinforce the group's goal.
  • The teacher models the strategy for the students.
  • The students practice the strategy with their independent books while teacher listens and coaches.
  • Review the strategy as a group.
  • Decide if students need to practice individually or with partners.
  • Plan the next meeting.
How long should the group meet?
The Sisters answer, "The approximate age of the students is the approximate number of minutes they can sustain higher-level thinking with group instructions." (page 115)

If the students aren't reading the same book, what can are some tools I can use to help teach the strategy?
The Sisters answered this question on the companion site for the books:  Materials.

When do I start pulling groups?  How do I manage strategy groups?
The beginning of the year (around the first five weeks) is spent assessing and conferring with students and getting the Daily Five running smoothly.  Since strategy groups are flexible and may not meet every day, an easy management system is needed to keep track.  On pages 111-113, the Sisters share their Strategy Groups form.


Looking for more Daily 5 and CAFE resources?  I have a Pinterest board that the authors of this blog have been pinning resources to as the book study occured and we will continue to pin resources.

 
Now it's your turn.  Talk to me about strategy groups:  Do you implement them?  What are your concerns?  What are your successes?  If you have questions, this is the place to ask them.  I may not be able to answer, but one of the wonderful people who have been following and commenting will be able to help you.

I am so glad that you have joined us for our first two book studies over the Daily Five and CAFE.  Stay tuned for our next book study.  We love having you here!

26 comments:

Wendy Zwart said...

I really like the flexible groups because you can group by skills and interests. I think it's important to help students identify others in class with similar interests.

Our students will begin school the last few weeks of August, so I think I will shoot for starting strategy groups at the interim...about 4 weeks into school. That should give me time to meet individually and review their DRAs.

I've enjoyed the study...the nagging question remains...grades? I think I've about decided that the skill taught as a whole group will be the skill graded for the week...comprehension, vocabulary, and writing skill...we shall see:)

Dennise said...

Thank you to all of the blog contributors. These book studies have been very enriching.

Strategy groups and traditional reading groups... I am going to try to do a bit of both (required to do the basal and ability groupings). As I am reading the blogs the strategy groups reminds me of the PLC (Professional Learning Communities) our district is implementing. I wish my team's goal was reading instead of math. I think CAFE would be a perfect foundation for our groupings.

Anonymous said...

The Cafe Book doesn't talk too much about grades, but by reading the book closely and visiting their Web site I've found the Sisters use Touch Points for their grades. You will see a column for Touch Points on their Strategy Groups and Instruction sheet and the Reading Conference sheet. When you meet with the student in a small group or individually you mark in the Touch Point column when he/she demonstrated use of the strategy he/she is currently working on. You could use a system such as the one used by the San Juan district wherein 1 is below, 2 is approaching, 3 is meeting, and 4 is exceeding. The student moves on to a new strategy when he/she has 4-5 Touch Points that are in the 3-4 range. You would also use the Touch Points as the student's grade.

Beth from Palatine

kdrex said...

I thought it would be difficult to go from a "guided" reading group model to strategy groups, but last year, as I began the 1:1 conferencing, the strategy groups seem to form themselves. I did a combination of both kinds of groups with conferencing. My challenge this year will be how to keep the groups shorter time. I had a hard time staying within 20 minutes with 5th graders. This year I have third graders and my entire class is Title I.

Please let me ask a question for a colleague who doesn't follow blogs. I know it is a bit off topic (Daily 5)but this is the group that will have the answer to this question-I just know it!!This year in fourth grade, they are departmentalizing. She will be teaching 80+ kids in four classes and is expected to implement Daily 5. How on earth does she handle the book boxes issue??? Would it be sufficient enough to expect kids to carry their independent reading book and response journal with them? Does anyone have an idea on how it could be done differently? Having taught 5th, I could see that work-those kids usually settle deeply into novels and chapter books but 4th grade could still be transitioning. I would love to be able to help her with some possible solutions. Thanks all.

Wendy Zwart said...

kdrex...I will have 67 students...in three classes. Each child has a bin. I have 6 shelves under my whiteboard space. Here's what I've seen and wish I had time to do. This teacher took two two-shelfed bookcases and turned them back to back. She attached a piece of round plyboard on top of the bookcases to extend over the bookshelves so that students could sit around them. She covered the plyboard top with a cute tablecloth and glued it down. They keep their bins and supplies right at their seats. With 4 groups rotating in, this might be a solution if she has time.

kdrex said...

Wow-that's ambitious, but a great idea.But then do I understand correctly that they still have to switch while carrying their bins? Wish I could see a picture of both those solutions. It's possible my friend could do the shelves the way you have done them.Thank you for your response.

Wendy Zwart said...

kdrex...the bins stay on the shelves when not in use. They don't take them with them when they switch. I have a picture of my bin storage, but not hers. I'll be glad to send it to your e-mail.

kdrex said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tracy said...

Although I only teach second grade, thank you so much for offering the "Book Club". I will be implementing both D% & Cafe next year (week!) and will be the only one at my site. i appreciate all of your comments and insights!

Wendy Zwart said...

kdrex...I sent you two pictures:)

kdrex said...

I posted on the Chap. 6 comments but I will put it here too...I think I sent everyone who asked, my rubric. If you didn't get it, or I missed you, please let me know.

Heather Arbuckle said...

I am a brand new blogger as of...TODAY! I must say though, I have been reading through the CAFE book as well, and I am loving it. I found it really interesting that the sisters stated that they only do strategy groups now vs. guided reading. It makes sense, though, when within your GR groups, you have kids that are needing support on varying strategies whether they are on the same "level" or not. I plan on implementing strategy groups 3 times a week during 1 of my daily 5 rotations. Slowly but surely I'd like to guide my students more towards strategy groups vs. guided reading! I love reading the discussions about this...helps me as I'm visualizing what CAFE will look like for me this next year.

Heather
Sensational Seconds

Margot Urmano said...

Hi kdrex, I posted under Chap 6 just today so you might miss my comment and request. I would love a copy of your rubric. I hope to get better with the rubrics and tying in both reading and writing with student expectations with assessment. Thank you so much!
meurmano@gmail.com

Dennise said...

Hi Kdrex, will you please send me your rubric too. Thanks for sharing.
dazredford@gmail.com

Melissa Groff said...

Kdrex, can I also get your rubric? melissa.m.groff@gmail.com

Thanks a bunch!

Melissa Groff said...

Does anyone find it to be a difficult transition to keep bringing students back for whole group lessons? Do you ever have a need to teach a longer whole group lesson rather than 3 mini lessons?

kdrex said...

Melissa,
I do and it is already causing me anxiety thinking about that issue for this year. This year my whole class is Title I and I NEED to see as many small groups as possible. I'm not sure how to do this but I do need to figure it out. Last year I observed a third grade teacher doing D5/Cafe and she actually broke up her Interactive read aloud on one picture book into three mini lessons. I'm not sure how I feel about that but I thought, depending on the book, it could work.

Rubrics coming to you.

Debbie Teise said...

Can not believe our book study is over! What's next? lol
Strategy groups actually seem daunting to me,even after 3 years of doing Cafe. Time is the issue on this end. I just have to stick to the schedule and see where it takes me this year.
regarding grades..someone posted on a blog or even during this Book Club that they do grades in this fashion..I am going to try and do the same.
Spelling Test
Comprehension Activities
Comprehension Quiz weekly
Writing/Rubric
Personally that seems like a fair assessment for The Cafe.
Hoping everyone has a wonderful start to their school year.
I am new to blogging so hopefully some of you will have a chance to check out Teise's Tidbits.

Debbie

P.S Thank you for sharing your great ideas this summer. :)

marycmc1 said...

I have truly enjoyed the book club on the Daily 5 and CAFE. Thank you all for your wisdom! I have to say I am feeling very anxious - almost not able to breathe- about implementing both this school year. Students arrive Tuesday. YIKES! I guess what is really pressing on me is do you still read books together(not read aloud) as a class? In the past we would have a novel, such as HOLES, and I would group students by level or allow them to read individually on their own depending which one they wanted to do at the time. The struggling readers would read with me. We would work on different comprehension activities depending on the novel. Is it my understanding that I do not necessarily do this anymore with Daily 5 & CAFE? They just read "Good Fit" books from their book boxes? Do I just integrate my novel sets into my library for them to choose on their own? Any advice or similar circumstances would be very helpful right now. I was thinking of doing the novel, but it would be a part of their book box. They would have to use their Daily 5 time to get through the book. But do I say, let's have 5 chapters read by Friday or do I just let them work at their own pace?

Grades are also a concern. I like what Debbie T posted above. I may have to take that to come up with how to grade for Daily 5 and CAFE. Thanks, Debbie.

Also, kdrex I would LOVE the rubric as well.

mhattabaugh@fms.k12.nm.us

Thank you again for everyone's insight!

Bee said...

I'd love the rubric also. Beeisme4@gmail.com
Thanks!
Bee
Bee Teaches

Mrs. Kingdon said...

Could I get a copy of your rubric as well!
Tkingdon@rrsd.mb.ca
Thanks

Anonymous said...

Thank you to everyone! May I also please get a copy of your grading rubric?
a2j2@cableone.net

Anonymous said...

This was a wonderful experience for me, being new to an online book study and D5 and Cafe. Thanks to the leaders for their thoughtful reflections and to those who commented. Also thanks for the freebies. I am excited and nervous to begin this with my Grade 6 class. May I also have a copy of the rubric?
cmpudwell@shaw.ca

Stephanie said...

Thank you for these book studies this summer! Re-reading the books and following along with you gave me the courage and drive to kick-start the D5 and CAFE in my 5th grade classroom this Fall. I have my pensieve ready-to-go, I've made my poster headers, I've picked up new reading material for my class library... I'm very excited and enthusiastic thanks to everyone here. All the best for the new school year!
Stephanie
Quebec, Canada

4C Sigman said...

I too have greatly enjoyed this book study. My book bins are filled. I'm nervous as I plan for my first ever try at D5 and CAFE, but I figure each part that I am able to implement is a step in the right direction. Thank you for all of the great ideas!

kdrex said...


marycmc1 - I ran Book Clubs with Daily 5 and also did a class novel-more like a shared novel last year in 5th. This really took the place of the mini-lesson. Each kid had a copy but I did the reading aloud. Kids would jot down their thinking on stickies and then we stopped to talk and share our thinking all together or in pairs or in their groups. It provided the model for their Book Clubs that I began after we had completed one novel. It takes some juggling but it can be done.

Post a Comment