Chapter 6 - Whole Class Instruction
Hi! I'm Jen from Runde's Room, and I'm so excited to be discussing chapter 6 with you. I teach a split grade 5/6 class (have taught a split class for 9 of my 11 teaching years), so one of the main reasons I chose this chapter is that I'm always looking for ways I can combine my classes so that I'm not teaching two separate classes whenever possible.
The CAFE Instruction Sequence: It's Your Choice
In this section, the sisters discuss the order and choices of order to teach the strategies on the CAFE menu. They have listed the strategies in the order they have used them in class - strategies near the top of the lists are used more frequently than others. Strategies near the bottom of the list are more sophisticated and are usually only taught in the upper elementary grades. It's good to know there is choice and flexibility in the order we choose to teach the strategies. I have also seen flexibility in the actual headings themselves - some of the bulletin boards I have seen rearrange the letters of CAFE to spell FACE - and call the bulletin board "The FACE of a Reader".
The sisters recommend teaching three whole-class strategy lessons a day - including one strategy from each of Comprehension and Accuracy, plus one more from either Fluency or Expand Vocabulary (all strategies in the CAFE menu are listed on page 143 in the appendix of the book). Fluency and vocabulary lessons can easily be integrated in whole-class read-alouds, or during Daily 5 stations like Listen to Reading, Read with a Partner, or Word Work.
Some questions I was left with in this section are:
- I absolutely LOVE the look of the CAFE menu bulletin boards I have seen. If you don't have the space in your classroom for such a large bulletin board, how are you planning to list the strategies for all to see?
- I have a 90 minute literacy block. With all I need to squeeze in, will it be possible to have 3 whole-class strategy lessons a day? How are you fitting in your strategy lessons - will you plan on having 3 a day?
Principles for Whole-Class Lessons
In this section, the sisters walk us through a typical whole-class strategy lesson. The first thing I was blown away by was the figure of a typical literacy block schedule. This schedule has over 3 hours of literacy instruction!!! I have half of that - one 90 minute block to fit it all in. I did really like how the strategy lesson was sequenced (more in the next section). I also really liked that a student took the ownership to create the strategy card to be placed on the bulletin board.
The importance of review and going back to the strategy was reinforced in this section - going back the next day, and throughout the year - something we all know is key to students mastering the concept. Students are also encouraged to try out the strategy during their "Read to Self" portion of the Daily 5, and share their finding with the class. I loved this because sometimes students don't even realize they are using the strategy until they hear a classmate discuss it - then the light bulb goes off, and they think, "Yeah - that's what I'm doing, too!".
Whole-Class Lesson Elements
The progression of steps to follow when introducing a new strategy are as follows:
1. Identify what is to be taught, and share "the secret to success" with the strategy. (The secret to success for each strategy is also listed in the appendix).
2. Teach the strategy - this should only take 1 - 5 minutes - students need the time to practice the strategy.
3. Students practice with partners. Students should already know who their partners are - this is one of the time-saving strategies I know I'll have to have in place.
4. Select a student to write and illustrate the CAFE Menu strategy card.
5. Review the strategy - during the wrap-up of the lesson.
6. Encourage practice during independent reading times.
7. Post the strategy AFTER independent practice.
8. Continually connect new strategies to strategies already on the board.
Some of the questions I was left with after this chapter are:
- I used to start my literacy block with independent reading (and I would conference with one or two students during this time). If my students should be practicing the CAFE strategy taught during independent reading, should I move my reading time? For those of you that have tried CAFE already in your classrooms, when do you have your students reading independently?
- Do you have your students create their own strategy cards? I have seen a lot of premade cards (that will look great on a bulletin board), but the sisters really recommended having the students create them. What do you do in your classroom?
- I'm thinking I will somehow mark our cards each time we connect to a card we have already discussed - to give a visual that shows how interconnected the strategies are - and how we are never "finished" with a strategy. Have any of you done this?
The rest of the chapter gives a sample lesson for each of the 4 CAFE categories. It was comforting to see how some of my favorite "tried and true" lessons will easily fit into these mini-lessons. I became even more excited to delve into the CAFE world after reading this chapter ... but I'm still trying to wrap my mind around the whole timing of it all. For those of you with a shorter literacy block (like myself), I would LOVE it if you would tell me some of your thoughts and plans to squeeze it all in - especially if you have already incorporated CAFE into your classroom.
I just wanted to leave you with one more thing: I've started a pinterest board full of CAFE ideas for this chapter. I've only just started it, so I will be adding lots of new ideas to it as I keep on planning this summer. Check it out and give it a follow - you may find exactly what you've been looking for. You can take a peek by clicking HERE.
Thanks for following along!






32 comments:
Why do some teachers change the heading to FACE? Isn't it just the same acronym in a different order?
I'm interested in hearing more SPECIFIC examples of how upper level teachers use the basal in the Daily 5/CAFE format
I agree with Amber. My district uses Harcourt Storytown and I am trying to figure out how to merge the two. I think I will use the literature selections to teach the whole class. I am not sure how assessments will work though if I don't use their skill sequence.
I need a chapter dedicated to report card assessment.
Strategy Lessons - I plan on having only two strategy lessons that will each be ten minutes long. I have only 52 minutes per period. I am also planning on implementing the writing VOICES "menu" to go along with the writing aspect of the common core.
Strategy Cards - I am going to create my own, because I teach five sections of the same class and I don't want to waste paper by creating one for each class period. I LOVE your idea of marking the cards each time two strategies are interconnected.
Any of you out there have short class period and are planning to run Daily 5? How are you doing it?
I have about an hour for Daily 5 and I'm still deciding if I want to do D5 this year or just do CAFE. If I do use Daily 5 it will probably be more like a Daily 2. One round each day will need to be Read to Self (I'll have all kids read at the same time) and the other will change from day to day. I don't think I'll include Work on Writing, because I'll have a separate writing block (1 hour). So, the second round will be Word Work (Wordly Wise) on Mondays and Fridays. On Mondays, the kids will choose an activity to complete as an intro to the week's lesson. On Fridays the kids will take the quiz (I know- not an ideal way to use D5 time, but it has to get done). Then on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays, I'll somehow alternate between Listen to Reading and Read to Someone.... I'm still deciding how I'll do it. I may even have 3 options for the second round. So I will have time for 2 mini-lessons and a wrap up each day. I hope that helps a little, Tina.
I will definitely do CAFE this year. I LOVE the idea of posting strategies for kids to see. It make everything so explicit. No excuses. I'm not sure if I'll use the acronym though. I'll still create a bulletin board, but not call it CAFE. It's just not really my thing.
I completely agree with having the kids write the strategy cards. It gives that child ownership, and I think I'll have a kid who needs to work on the strategy write the card for it.
I will only have a 90min block for each class...so I plan to try a D3 and teach two strategies. I am concerned because we are doing "Write From the Beginning" which will be included in those 90 minutes. We also have a new basal series...our students are grouped by DRA and I am expected to meet with three groups a day for each class....wonder how in the world this will all work...I only have one week to figure it out...school starts back for me on Tuesday of next week.
I think I will use FACE instead of CAFE. We are the Panthers...so I think mine will say "The FACE of a Pawesome Panther".
With three classes and only one strategy board, I will probably write the strategy cards...not the best way, but the best I can manage.
I was wondering how to manage the Class Word Catcher with three classes?
Grades...yikes...I've got to know. How do you get them? My parents will want concrete proof of grades. I have to send graded papers home each week. Anyone out there that has used CAFE/D5 have any words of wisdom?
Thanks for sharing your CAFE Pinterest, Jen!
With so many expectations from the school board and ministry, I find it difficult to do that true D5. I usually end up with a daily 3. Do most of you do this every day? Do you skip days and do your assessments and critical pathways stuff? I have 100 minutes blocked for literacy. I will start my year out with the D5 and see where it goes.
Well, I think I have a lot more flexibility than a lot of you describe. We have a guided reading program as well as a whole group program (two different systems) but I can use them at my leisure. Our district believes that teachers should be trusted to make judgements on what materials to use. Anyway, I say that to say that I have lots of materials to use to teach CAFE in my 4th grade classroom. I too was wondering how I will adapt this for my reading block. I have two hours each afternoon for Reading and Writing. I think I will do Daily 3 for the most part but there will be some readers who need Read to Someone and Listen to Reading. I think word work will be one of my greatest challenges to have materials for each day. I have magnet words/letters and cookie sheets, spelling city will be an option and I am building a BOGGLE board as well. I think this will get old after the first month but I don't know what else to have for older students. I really want to have the kids make the strategy cards each day. If I write out the sticky notes ahead of time and put it in my lesson plans then it will be ready to go. Keeping a marker, and sentence strips in the area will also help.
I also have to work within the limits of a 90-min. reading block. I only have time for two mini lessons, one of which ends up being a lesson from our mandated vocabulary program. So I do one CAFE strategy lesson a day. Is it ideal? Probably not, but it's what I can do. Do I have time to meet with multiple strategy groups AND conference with individual students everyday? Nope. I have to alternate a week or so of strategy groups with a series of individual conferences. Do I have room on my wall for multiple class Word Collectors? Does anyone? I keep mine as separate files on my ActivBoard and pull them up as needed. I love what the Sisters have done to change the way teachers think about teaching reading. But you have to make it work for you. Don't get discouraged because you can't "do it all." I have to believe that it is better for me to do a few deliberate things well, than a bunch of things in a chaotic malestrom of good intentions. Each year I try to do a little better and tell myself that's good enough.
Great comment lbbeck! I agree it's better to do a few things well.
I'm going to start slow - and add on as I go. I am limited to a 90 minute block and have to do 20 minutes of interventions for my Tier 3 group. I'm not sure how I'm going to schedule my block yet. I have 2 weeks to figure it out.
I'm going to let the students make the strategy cards - it will help them take ownership.
If you had more than one class, though I could see how that would be difficult. Maybe you have each class keep their own menu in a binder to add to and have teacher-made strategies for the board.
Love the list of books that help to build vocabulary on page 103. Hoping to use some of these titles in my lessons this year. I am going to be more mindful of using a strategy from not only the Comprehension column but from the Accuracy and Fluency column this year. I feel like over the past 3 years I gravitate to the Comprehension and the Expand Vocabulary quite a bit. Pacing myself will be the key. Also like the list of elements on pgs. 95-97..will be able to insert some of those "buzz" words into my lesson plans.
As always..thank you for sharing. Seems hard to believe that our Book Club is coming to an end on the 9th! What will we do???
I taught 5th grade last year and I pulled a grade every week from a letter the kids had to write to me about their thinking while reading. I developed a rubric for this and the grade. I only taught my homeroom reading so I don't know how "doable" this is for more than one class. I guess you could do it bi-weekly and rotate your classes.
I absolutely believe the kids should write the strategy. I have seen the CAFE board done on a trifold presentation board.
I will be teaching 4th grade for the first time and implementing a Daily 3 for the first time also. I appreciate your pinterest board of ideas.Since my students will have had Daily 5 the past two years, I'm thinking most of them will have heard the shoe example for a good fit. I'm considering using gloves instead to give them some variety.
I too will only have about 90 min. for my reading time (split by specials). I think I'll have the students write the strategy cards, but the ones on your pinterest site are sure nice! I feel like I will need to begin the class with a strategy secret lesson. I appreciate the lesson examples. They are giving me more confidence in getting things started! Thanks for your good review.
kdrex- Would you be interested in sharing your rubric for your letters? I like the idea of students writing to me, but unsure about scoring them for reading assessments. I'm used to scoring them for 6 + 1.
I will score the letters according to the reading standards/strategies that I'm required to teach by my county. So many of them match what is already on the CAFE menu anyhow and if they are not I have have added them
I would be happy to share my rubric if someone would tell me how to attach it. I could also email it to you.
Love the idea of a tri-fold strategy board for my classes...I could do the same for the word catcher. Thanks kdrex! I would love to see the rubric,also. If you wouldn't mind e-mailing it...I am wzwart@lex3.k12.sc.us
I really appreciate all of the great ideas shared:)
kdrex: I would also LOVE to have a copy of your rubric!!!! It stinks we can't attach things to our posts:(
pkteaches@gmail.com
Kdrex: I would also like to have a copy of your rubric. It sounds like a good way to get a grade. I was wanting them to write me weekly on their reading, but I could vary it. Thanks again.
Debbie: I agree about the closure of our book study. It would be great if we could continue with a Daily5/Cafe blog or something to keep us (actually me) grounded and invigorated. I know I will be feeling overwhelmed for one and a montage of feelings. I like the way we've been able to connect and gain ideas from one another. If anyone has an idea for this, please share.
Tammy Hubbart
I'd also like to see the rubric and it would be great to keep in touch or keep blogging with updates on our progress this school year.
melstutt@hotmail.com
kdrex: Sorry here's my email for the rubric thubbart@usd205.com
Thanks again.
Tammy Hubbart
I would also like to see the rubric (rachael.stube@gmail.com). I think it would be good to check in with each other with successes and questions. It might help keep us on track at the beginning. Who is running this blog? Is it possible to keep it going?
I really like the explicit instruction for comprehension. I will be using these ideas this year. I found a short chapter book to use as a read aloud (Pinky and Rex and the Spelling Bee by James Howe) during the first week so we can stop and review quite often. I think the more we apply the reading instruction in the beginning the better off we will be. I am also hoping to share some of these ideas with friends at work.
I am teaching 6th grade for the first time and I have to figure out how to fit Reading, ELA & Writing into a 90 minute block. I have taught 2nd grade for the past 5 years and was self contained but now I'm going to have 70 students rotating in and out of my classroom and I just don't think I can incorporate D5 into my class. I have decided to just have the student do an Independent Reading time each day. At this time I will conference using strategies from the CAFE. I still don't know how I'm going to also fit in a small group during this time either!
Anyone else teach 6th grade? How are you going to do this? HELP! (
kdrex -- I would also love a copy of the rubric. What a creative and insightful way to get a grade. If you could please e-mail it to me at jmkegley2@gmail.com, that would be great.
I have to say I was excited to find the "Awareness" (the "A" of CAFE)on some of the sites. This is to be used in place of "Accuracy." I'll be teaching 4th grade gifted and was afraid that the Accuracy piece was too primary for my kiddos. I think "Awareness" will provide them with some great additional skills.
I've enjoyed this blog tremendously and have learned tons! It's been great hearing everyone's ideas. Thank you all!
I use the basal anthology as my read aloud to model the strategies for students. Since the stories are excertps from novels, they are a better length to use for whole class mini lessons than novels.
You have to read Cafe closely to get pick up what the Sisters say about assessments...they are using the Touch Points on their Reading Conference forms for grades. They note when the student exhibits use of the strategy as a Touch Point. The number of Touch Points let's you know when the student has mastered the strategy and is ready to move on to another strategy. The number of Touch Points also lets you know how well a student is doing and that is what you can then use for an assessment and grade ibn reading.
Beth from Palatine
Wow, this has been a great chapter blog. We started school yesterday. I had high ambitions of introducing D5 and 3 CAFE lessons a day. Too much. Even during these first few "get to know you days". I ended up doing 2 CAFE lessons instead. BUT the student responses and insights made it well worth it. Last year I used D5 and I hoping to really jump into CAFE this year. Today the students enthusiasm reassured me that this was a good idea.
I worry about time like everyone else. I plan to use the required basal vocabulary and spelling sheets for Word Work and just change up the activities so it isn't always a worksheet (which I will use as a grade). For conferences I hope the conference calendar keeps me going. I am going to use parent volunteers to run my basal reading groups when I can, try the conferencing and work with my intensive need readers when the volunteers are in. Keep your fingers crossed for me. Just a bit of advice from one of my students today when I asked them what ideas they had to help those who were struggling with stamina..." just set a goal of where you want to be (in the book)and tune everything out so you can get there." So simple. Yes, he tried it and said it helped :) (Touch points are still confusing to me but I will give it a try)
I think I sent everyone who asked, my rubric. I also included the letter I wrote explaining the task. It was amazing to see how their thinking and writing about their think changed over the course of the year. If I missed someone, please let me know. Also, if any of you are third grade teachers and could suggest how I need to change it for third grade, please tell me. I am still struggling with that and I do want to have them write to me each week.
"Don't get discouraged because you can't 'do it all.' I have to believe that it is better for me to do a few deliberate things well, than a bunch of things in a chaotic malestrom of good intentions. Each year I try to do a little better and tell myself that's good enough." I think I am going to type this up and paste it into my lesson plans!! I love it!
5B Sigman-I used barbells this year. I lugged a 2 pound,10 pound and 25 pound weight in to my class and left them in my gathering area with strict instructions not to touch them. Kids couldn't figure out what I was going to do with them. My mini lesson was a weight training analogy. When they got the connection- you should have seen some of their faces! This was not my idea. I believe I saw it on the Sister's site or maybe Choice Literacy.
kdrex-I would also love to see the rubric you use. (klump1971@gmail.com)
I will be implementing D5 and CAFE for the first time this year.
I also am hoping this blog will continue throughout the school year. I have really gotten a great deal out of it. Thanks everyone!
Hi kdrex, like others. I would love to seeyour rubric as well. Getting reading grades in a workshop forum has to get creative. Being able to track students progress in mastering their specific strategies is the ipedomy of differentiation. Thank you so much, in advance!
meurmano@gmail.com
kdrex- Great idea using the barbells, but what a lot to lug to school!!:)
Amazing what we are willing to do to reach our students!
Post a Comment